Teacher in Role – what makes it successful
15th December 2025
This article was first published in the NATD Journal for Drama Education, Vol. 40 Issue 1, Autumn 2025
I guess if you’re reading this article, you already know what teacher in role is. In fact, one of the most amazing aspects of this approach is that even young children seem to know what it is, intuitively. I remember working with a class of 4- and 5-year-olds. We were reading We’re Going on a Bear Hunt. You can imagine the scene: us getting up whenever the family in the book reached a challenge and acting it out (is that the right term? Terms can be very tricky in this work. Some people might say pretending is a better description, others might argue Enacting is more technically precise?). Anyway, we’re all on our feet joining in with the family, doing the actions: “We can’t go over it,” we shout, “we can’t go under it, we’ll have to go through it! Swishy-swashy, swishy-swashy, swishy-swashy.”
You get the picture.
At the very end of the book is a double-page picture you could easily miss, of the bear trudging home along the beach, its shoulders hunched, its head bowed, its face staring at the sand. It’s dusk and the sun is going down over the sea, giving the picture an air of melancholy. I hold the picture up to the children. They look intently. The wrong thing to do at this stage, I think, would be to ask them, “How do you think the bear feels?” It’s one of those questions that goes nowhere – “Sad” is the likely answer. I could ask, as a follow-up, “Why do you think he’s sad?” but I’m not sure they’d know and, besides, it’s a boring question. After all the excitement, I’ve likely lost half the class.
The right thing is to keep the energy in the room and direct it into a purpose. So, I use teacher in role. I say to the children, “When I stand up, I’m going to be the bear on the beach at the end of the story. See what you think.” I stand up, slump my shoulders and walk a few steps like the bear. Then I sit back down. “What do you think?” I ask. “I think he’s sad,” one of the children says. “I think he’s lonely,” says another.
I ask them, “Would you like to talk to the bear? He’s quite friendly, just very unhappy.” The children say they would. I say, “Well then, you’ll have to come into the story. Stand up.” The children stand up and I narrate: “The bear trudged along the beach, he stared at the sand. Would you all like to be the bear?” They say they would, so we all start trudging along as I continue: “The bear trudged along the beach, he stared at the sand. His shoulders slumped, his mouth turned down in a sad frown. He could hear the sea lapping against the shore, but he wasn’t interested. All he wanted to do now was get home to his cave. There it was, just up ahead, a dark hole in the cliff face. He went inside and sat down, dejected.”
I sit down and indicate for the children to do the same. We’re all now together on the carpet. I speak as the bear: “Humph, I’m so lonely. Why does everyone run away from me? I just want to be their friend.” I look at the children as if they are there with me in the cave. “What can I do?” Then I straighten up and talk to the children outside the fiction: “Did you hear what the bear said?” And we continue.
I’ll pause there. It’s worth noticing what the children just did with their brains. At first glance it looks like simple pretending, yet it’s far more complex. When I stood up and said I was going to be the bear, the children understood at once that I was still their teacher, but for a moment I was also taking the role of the bear. To hold those two ideas in mind at once is no small achievement. In my experience, very young children can’t manage it, but by four or five they are beginning to make this imaginative leap.
Then, when they joined me in role, they went further still. They didn’t only copy the action – they connected it to feelings. “He’s sad.” “He’s lonely.” In that moment they were doing something really sophisticated: picturing the inner life of another being. I believe psychologists call this “theory of mind,” and it remains one of the most remarkable things human beings can do. It isn’t “just pretending.” It’s empathy in action – children using imagination to step into another perspective and build meaning together.
And here’s another thing. Nobody had to teach the children how to do this. Nobody sat them down and explained how to step into a role, or how to imagine another’s inner world. They simply did it. That tells us something important: this isn’t a skill invented in classrooms; it’s a deep human capacity that children bring with them.
It must have evolved. At some point in our long and distant past, our ancestors who could imagine what others were thinking or feeling had an advantage. If you could picture what the hunter beside you might do next or guess whether the stranger at the edge of the fire was a threat or a friend, you were more likely to survive. Being able to anticipate, cooperate, and plan together would have made groups stronger. Story, play, and role-taking aren’t just entertainment, they are rehearsal spaces for some of the most essential of human capacities.
Using drama for learning then, is not just an add-on or a stand-alone lesson, it is a way of harnessing something deeply human and putting it to work in the classroom. At the centre, perhaps the most important of all the strategies used in drama for learning, is the use of teacher in role. It is the catalyst, the engine, the organiser, director, and mediator of the fiction: taking it forward, creating tension, and interacting with the students inside the imaginary world. Thinking about how to do it well is therefore important. It is a pedagogy of practice, something worth rehearsing, reflecting on, and refining. I’m not suggesting there is a single best way of doing it – in fact that would be wrong. Like any artistic endeavour, there are many different forms and ways of interpreting. My suggestion is that we take it seriously and study it as an essential part of teaching – something that should be taught on every teacher training programme and embedded into every school INSET.
All that said, what follows is simply my take – my thoughts on what I know at the moment about teaching in role and how to use it successfully. You might disagree, and that’s fine. This isn’t a definitive answer, just my current view. I’m going to try to avoid giving you a neat list – lists are deadly – though inevitably the ideas will fall into a range of categories. The first is this: avoid acting. Acting in this work is a distraction. It turns the children into an audience and sends the message to those who aren’t comfortable performing that “this isn’t for you.” Keep it simple, keep it genuine. Don’t do too much – less is more in this work.
When I stood up to represent the bear, I didn’t try to be the bear. I tried to capture the mood of the picture and focus on his actions. If I had thought about acting like a bear, I would probably have ended up making a mess of it – or making the children laugh. That’s the problem with acting: unless you’re really good at it (which I’m not), it tends to get in the way.
Next: be careful not to confuse the children. It’s surprisingly easy to do. Most of us who have tried drama have our own horror stories about a drama session where the line between fiction and reality got blurred and the children weren’t sure what to believe. In my case, the worst was a queue of parents at my classroom door the following morning, all wanting to know why their children hadn’t slept after the ghost story we’d explored the day before.
It took me a while to understand this. Eventually I realised it has to do with signalling. Think about when you go to the theatre, or the cinema, or turn on a drama on the TV, or open a fiction book. Each of these, in their different ways, signals that there are two worlds here, the world of the fiction, which you’re outside, and the real world you are in. Imagine how terrifying it would be watching Richard III if you didn’t know it was a fiction. The man has just confessed to a murder and is planning a series of others. Yet we know it is not really happening because the stage, the lighting, and the curtain give us the signs that this is fiction. We can become incredibly engrossed and invested in the characters and the outcome, but we are always perfectly safe.
Now transfer that thought to the classroom and drama for learning. In this context there is very little to protect the children into the experience and to make it clear where the fiction begins, or even if it is fiction.
Here’s an example, offered as a cautionary tale.
After my dad retired – he’d been a teacher and headteacher for thirty-five years – he got a part-time job working in a museum. The museum had once been a workhouse and still had a Victorian classroom. My dad’s job was to dress up as a Victorian teacher – stiff collar, long coat, and a cane tucked under his arm – and when the children came in he would look sternly at them and bark in a commanding voice, “Sit down!” After a couple of weeks I phoned him and asked how it was going. “Not bad,” he said, “the only problem is some of the children cry.” “That doesn’t sound good!” I said, “What are you doing?” He explained about dressing up and barking. I said, “There’s your problem, they don’t know who you are. They know it’s a fiction (at least I think they do), but they don’t know you. They don’t know if you – Tony – are just like that Victorian teacher, or if you’re acting.”
“Yes,” he agreed. “So what should I do?”
We talked about it some more and he decided he would hang his long coat on a hook alongside the cane. When the children came in, he would welcome them as Tony and say, “In a moment I’m going to put on this coat and pick up this cane. When I do that, I’m going to become a Victorian teacher. How do you suppose I’ll behave?”
This way he would be involving the children in the creation of the fiction and making it clear from the start that it was not real, that it could stop at any moment, and that they were all perfectly safe.
Having said all that, let’s now return to the Bear Hunt lesson and look at what I did to make it clear to the children where the fiction began. To start with, we had the book. The children were familiar with books and understood how they worked. Like most children, they enjoyed stories and liked joining in with the parts they knew well. What they hadn’t experienced, as far as I know, was their teacher stepping into role and inviting them to join in.
So I began with a simple instruction: “When I stand up, I’m going to be the bear on the beach at the end of the story. See what you think.” Notice how much is packed into that one line. The children already knew who I was – Mr Taylor, the teacher – so there was no confusion about identity. What the line gave them was clarity: what I was going to do (“when I stand up”), who I was going to represent (“the bear”), where it was happening (“on the beach”), and when (“at the end of the story”). No surprises, nothing to trip them up.
Then I performed the action. I slumped my shoulders, trudged a few steps, and sat back down and came out of the fiction. Immediately after, I asked, “What do you think?” On the surface this looks very mundane, but I’d argue it’s one of the most important strategies a teacher in role can use. Get the opening wrong and the whole thing can unravel – just ask my dad.
As Luke Abbott has often pointed out, this is best understood not just as teacher in role but as “teacher in and out of role.” First I was out of role, explaining the context. Then, for a moment, I stepped in, showing the action. Then I was back out again, asking a question. Out, in, out. That rhythm is crucial: it gives children both the fiction to encounter and the security of knowing the teacher is still there, guiding.
Even in that short instruction – “When I stand up, I’m going to be the bear on the beach at the end of the story” there are three of the five elements of story: character, location, and time. When I enacted the role, I added the other two: events and tension. In less than half a minute, the children had everything they needed to understand the context and make meaning. They knew where the fiction began and ended, what was happening, and where they were in relation to events. It wasn’t complicated, it didn’t need me to explain to them how it worked, it just needed some clear descriptions and a set of simple actions they could make sense of.
My next suggestion is to avoid hot-seating. Hot-seating is one of those drama strategies we learn early, probably because it’s quite easy to organise – “When I sit on the chair I’m going to be the bear, what would you like to ask?” The problem is that it blurs the line between the real world and the fiction. The character is inside the fiction, but the people asking the questions are outside. This doesn’t make sense if you care about the coherence of the work. A much better strategy, in my opinion, is to find a way to bring the students into the fiction, to cast them in a role that gives them a reason to interact with the teacher’s role, or at least to be in the same space.
Let’s look at a different example. Imagine the teacher is representing Henry VIII. The students have been studying the Tudors for a while, and the teacher decides they are ready to meet the king. He shows them a picture of Henry and says, “When I sit on the chair, I’ll be Henry. Think about what you’d like to ask him.”
The teacher sits down and the students begin asking questions. Because they’ve been studying the period for a while, their questions are good: “Why were you so desperate for a son?” “Why did you execute Anne Boleyn?” And because the teacher is well prepared, he gives them good answers.
On the surface, this seems to work well. But here’s the problem: the children are still outside the fiction, questioning a role that is inside. It’s incoherent and carries very little, if any, tension.
Now imagine the teacher tries it another way. He says, “I’m going to show you a painting of Henry, from towards the end of his life. See what you notice.” There’s a discussion. Then: “Now when I sit on this chair, I’m going to represent Henry at the time this painting was made. Can you imagine, for a moment, that you are the artist commissioned to create this picture? It’s a great honour, but not entirely comfortable – you’ve heard all about the king’s reputation. Could you stand for a moment and gather round? Just imagine you’re at the early stages of the process. You might be sketching in your book, or mapping the outline of Henry’s body. Will you be truthful? He’s not a man who is easily flattered. I’ll be Henry for a moment. Let’s see what happens.”
The teacher sits in the chair and becomes the king. He’s not in a good mood: he rubs his leg and winces, stretches his neck, adjusts his clothes. He stares with harsh eyes at the artist. “Is this going to take long?” he growls.
The teacher comes out of role: “What do you make of that?” The students discuss Henry’s mood and discomfort. Then he adds, “I wonder what you would ask him, if you could. You’d have to be careful, of course. You’d need to put him at his ease. But maybe, if he felt he could trust you, he might open up. After all, these paintings take a long time – you’ll be alone together for weeks. He’s lived a long life. I wonder if he has any regrets.”
In the Bear Hunt example this process is a lot less involved. I simply said, “Would you like to talk to the bear? He’s quite friendly, just very unhappy.” And then, “Well then, you’ll have to come into the story. Stand up.” This was enough to bring the students into the same world as the bear. At this stage they didn’t have a point of view, but my next question, “Would you all like to be the bear?” gave them the opportunity to take on the role. For me, this part of the process is essential and I think about it carefully. The wording is important, and structuring it so that it makes sense to the students and brings them into the fiction as characters with a point of view is what gives the work coherence and dramatic tension.
My last suggestion is to use narration. Narration can be extremely helpful if not overused. For me it has four main purposes, as illustrated by the Bear Hunt example. The first is to give a description of the role’s behaviour, a kind of story-telling voice alongside the teacher-in-role and the students’ actions: “The bear trudged along the beach, he stared at the sand.” The second is to give access to some of the character’s thoughts and feelings: “He could hear the sea lapping against the shore, but he wasn’t interested. All he wanted to do now was get home to his cave.” The third is a description of the scene, often giving detail and colour: “There it was, just up ahead, a dark hole in the cliff face.” The fourth is a way of moving the story forward, giving it direction and momentum: “He went inside and sat down, dejected.” Each of these purposes is designed to help the students making meaning and to give the drama a sense of story book action.
Let’s look at how they might apply in the Henry VIII example.
- Description of the role’s behaviour. “Henry paced backwards and forwards across the room. He walked over to the table and picked up the quill. A sheet lay waiting on the desk; it sat there like an accusation. He hesitated and then signed his name as quickly as the nib could travel across the page.”
- Give access to some of the character’s thoughts and feelings. “That would put an end to it,” he thought to himself, “though he knew it was a lie.”
- Description of the scene, often giving detail and colour. “Outside he could hear the sound of the palace – people talking, horses being returned to their stables, musicians tuning their instruments – just an ordinary day. Except it would be remembered forever in history.”
- Moving the story forward. “Henry dropped the quill and sealed the letter with hot wax. He pressed the mark of authority and called for Cromwell, waiting outside the door. The deal was done. God would now be his witness.”
A word of warning, though. Narration is powerful, but it’s also easy to overuse. As I said earlier, less is more in this work, and there is a danger that with too much narration the children end up simply acting out your story. This is not a situation you want to be in. The aim is to give them just enough to step into the fiction, not to script their every move. If you tell them everything the character thinks, feels, and does, you leave no space for their imagination. And it’s not only the drama that suffers. Meaning-making itself depends on those spaces – the moments where children test ideas, interpret, and bring their own sense of things. That’s where the learning happens. Drama for learning is, at its best, a form of dramatic inquiry: a process where students and teacher together explore, question, and make meaning through the fiction.
So there it is, that’s my current thinking on what helps make teacher in role successful in the classroom: don’t try to be an actor – be simple and authentic; be careful not to confuse the students – clearly signal the boundary between fiction and reality; avoid hot-seating – keep coherence by bringing the students into the fiction; and use narration – for description, access to thoughts and feelings, scene-setting, and momentum. To me these feel like straightforward principles, things most teachers can work with and develop. Of course there are other possibilities and some people might disagree with the things on my list, but I’m happy with them for now and they have come out of practice, reflection, and study.