Belonging: What Happened When a Young Person Was Given a Real Commission

19th September 2026

Iona Towler-Evans

“I am not wanted here.”
Richard Burton, aged 15, 1941

“I never felt needed at school; they never wanted me there.”
Assim Amari, aged 16, 2016

This is a story about two young people, separated by more than seventy years, but connected by the same place: Port Talbot. One was Richard Burton who became one of the most famous actors of his generation. The other , Assim, was a student, at risk of NEET (not in education , employment or training), who had struggled at school and had lost faith that education, and perhaps the town itself , had much to offer him.

Their lives , in many ways seemed very different,  but during a two-year project I began to see unexpected connections between them.

The project grew from Dorothy Heathcote’s Commission Model, an approach to teaching in which young people are given purposeful work on behalf of someone else. Rather than completing an exercise simply because a teacher has asked them to, they take responsibility for something that matters beyond the classroom.

In this case, the students were invited by Sally Burton, Richard Burton’s surviving wife, to find a way of honouring his life in the town where he grew up.

The students decided to make a film.

This meant researching Burton’s life, reading about his diary which had been gifted to Swansea University by his widow Sally Burton, talking to people in the local community, interviewing members of his family,  visiting locations significant to his life and thinking carefully about how his story should be represented. As Assim said on one of our field trips, ‘ Our feet tread where his feet have trod’ The actor Michael Sheen, who also grew up in the area, made himself available to be interviewed as part of their research.

For Assim, the commission became much more than an investigation into the life of a famous actor.

As he learned more about Richard Burton, he began to recognise aspects of Burton’s early life that resonated with his own experience: uncertainty, difficulty, feelings of rejection, and questions about belonging. He drew from his own experience which connected with that of Richard Burton as he was growing up and was drawn into  Burton’s journey. He saw him less as a film star and more as  an ordinary human being from an ordinary town, confronting challenges and dilemmas, and difficult decisions. Should he move in with Mr Burton, his teacher, leaving his beloved Cis who had  cared for him since his mother died when he was aged three? Should he return to school or continue working at the co-op to help the family’s finances? Should he leave Port Talbot to pursue a career in Hollywood? Although this was Burton’s story , it was also Assim’s. story. On the cusp of adulthood, what was his future? Should he stay in Port Talbot and refuse to leave with his mother who planned for them to go to America? He identified with Burton whose life, like his ,had been dictated by circumstances. Assim had attended eight schools by the time he reached sixteen. He seemed to be making sense of his own life by being in dialogue with the life of Richard Burton.

My aim was to locate aspects of the work which changed the position of students, afforded them agency and shifted their identity. Assim was very drawn to words, in particular the words of Burton at 14 in his diary:

“I am not wanted here.”
Richard Burton, aged 15, 1941

Later , his own diary revealed 

“I never felt needed at school; they never wanted me there.”
Assim Amari, aged 16, 2016

The life of Burton provided the ‘other’ which protected him from exploring his own  feelings of insecurity, which he later shared with me in our conversation. Assim liked words and he often talked in metaphors .It seemed a protective way for him to describe his feelings. He used the metaphors of the green dragon and the red dragon, which represented his moods. He said;

‘There are two dragons, red and green they are fighting, the one who survives is the one you decide to feed. I try to feed the green dragon. This project is feeding me new insights,  a new me, a new goal.’

One of Dorothy Heathcote’s great insights was that young people can behave differently when the work they are doing has purpose, when their contribution is needed, and when they are treated as people capable of making meaningful decisions.

I saw something of that happening with Assim. Perhaps more significantly for me, it gave me an insight into what the story of another tells us about ourselves. The story of Burton acted as an ‘other’ in Assim’s life . As Heathcote says, ‘the other be the gateway to be all the full depth of exploration which will follow’. 

Near the end of the project, in June 2018, we had a conversation I have never forgotten.

“I am not leaving Port Talbot,” he told me quietly. “This is my home now. I belong here.”

There was a certainty in the way he said it that I had not seen before.

Of course, no educational project can provide a simple explanation for changes in a young person’s life. Lives are far more complicated than that. But over two years, I had watched Assim begin to describe himself differently and imagine his future differently.

That experience eventually became part of my PhD research into the use of Dorothy Heathcote’s Commission Model with young people considered at risk of becoming NEET – not in education, employment or training.

But the experience also left me with a question that reaches beyond my research.

When we select content for any of Heathcote’s models of learning, how far do we consider, or pay attention to the lives of the people who will encounter that content and how it might connect to their own lives? In this commission the work was meaningful to Assim because he identified with the journey of a young boy confronting decisions and struggling with them and to a degree overcoming them as Burton developed his acting career. For Assim ,the story of Richard Burton spoke to him.  He identified with Burton’s life experience growing up and it gave him the courage to make bold changes in his own life.

What might happen if more young people experienced education not simply as a series of tasks they were required to complete, but as meaningful work in which somebody genuinely needed their contribution?

Perhaps one of the most important things education can offer is not simply knowledge or qualifications, important though both are.

Perhaps it can also offer young people the experience of being needed, trusted and able to contribute – and, through that experience, a stronger sense  of their own identity and a sense that they belong.


My Phd ‘A Narrative Inquiry into the Experience of Using Dorothy Heathcote’s Commission Model with Young People, at risk of NEET (Not in Education, Employment or Training) in a College in Port Talbot’
Iona Towler-Evans can be accessed via the following link https://newman.repository.guildhe.ac.uk/id/eprint/17407

Newsletter

Keep up-to-date with the latest news and projects.

Mailing List