Mantle of the Expert and the Nine Hallmarks of Great Pedagogy

5th July 2025

Tim Taylor

Like the ruins of the Temple of Claudius in Colchester, after the Iceni had set their torches to it, the National College for School Leadership (NCSL) is now mostly forgotten in the smoke of time. A victim of the Govian passion for crushing anything that hinted at Blairite direction or purpose in education.

Yet, in its heyday the NCSL was a buzzing hive of educational activity, conducting research, running training courses, and generally doing its best to promote good practice. It didn’t always get things right and inevitably there were some who despised it for its ‘blob’ outlook. So, when the wheel turned (like much in the history of education) there was a bonfire of the vanities and the NCSL was swept away, along with much of the things it had learned, both good and bad.

This, however, should not stop us from raking through the ashes and looking for things that might still be of value: Not all that is blobby is bad.

One document, now burned at the edges and covered in soot, is a paper called What Makes Great Pedagogy? Nine Claims from Research, created by researchers Chris Husbands and Jo Pearce which draws together evidence from a broad range of international studies in an effort to define what characterises high-quality teaching. Its aim was not to prescribe a single method of teaching, but to distil a set of shared principles that consistently lead to powerful learning across different contexts.

The result is a framework built around, what they call, ‘nine interrelated hallmarks of effective pedagogy’:

  1. Serious attention to pupil voice
  2. Strong teacher knowledge, behaviour, and beliefs
  3. Long-term learning goals
  4. Building on prior learning
  5. Effective scaffolding
  6. Use of a range of techniques
  7. Higher-order thinking and dialogue
  8. Formative assessment practices
  9. Inclusion and equity

Husbands and Pearce argue that these features, when used together, describe the kind of teaching that engages learners deeply, supports professional judgement, and leads to meaningful educational outcomes. They shift the focus away from short-term fixes and towards sustained, thoughtful practice that adapts to learners’ needs and fosters development over time

Reading through this list it is difficult to imagine anyone disagreeing fundamentally with these hallmarks (although I have heard some on social media disparaging ‘pupil voice’ as if children don’t deserve a say in their community) yet I don’t remember seeing these aspects given the attention they deserve.

To my mind, any teaching approach should be evaluated alongside this list. The question is: does this pedagogy meet the requirements of great teaching? The rest of this document is an argument to say Mantle of the Expert does.

Mantle of the Expert and the Nine Hallmarks of Great Pedagogy
Although it was first developed more than twenty years before the paper was written, Dorothy Heathcote’s approach of Mantle of the Expert captures all the hallmarks identified by this research. It sits firmly within the paradigm of authentic teaching and learning, drawing on principles from social constructivism, dialogic teaching, and imaginative inquiry. It rests on the belief that students learn best when they have agency, when their learning is purposeful, and when it is shaped by an immediate context and positive relationships in the classroom.

1 Pupil Voice
MoE takes pupil voice seriously not as an optional addition but as a central structuring principle. In MoE contexts, learners are cast as responsible participants in a fictional enterprise such as scientists, engineers, artists, or rescue teams, entrusted with meaningful tasks. They help make decisions, influence direction, and interpret events within the story world. This participatory structure ensures that students’ perspectives and ideas actively shape the narrative, encouraging a genuine sense of ownership and engagement. MoE also values the plurality of voices. Different children contribute in different ways, and the approach is flexible enough to listen to the quiet, the hesitant, and the resistant, not just the articulate and eager.

2 Teacher Behaviour, Knowledge, and Beliefs
MoE places high expectations on teachers. It relies on their ability to plan responsively, work improvisationally, and think carefully about the use of language, questioning, and tone. It draws on deep subject knowledge, alongside dramatic skill and a belief in the transformative power of imagination. Teachers using MoE act not deliverers of content but mediators between the students and the curriculum. Their actions are guided by a belief in student capability, collaboration, and the co-construction of understanding. This belief system is visible in the way they build fictional contexts together with students and hold space for uncertainty, dialogue, and discovery.

3 Long Term Learning Goals
MoE encourages both short term skill development and long-term growth. Because contexts are sustained over time, they allow for deepening complexity, reflection, and re-engagement with core concepts. For example, a context involving a humanitarian aid team might explore geography, ethics, science, and literacy over several weeks, returning to key questions about justice, responsibility, and impact. The longer-term aim is to build resilient, thoughtful learners who see knowledge as interconnected and purposeful.

4 Building on Prior Learning
A hallmark of MoE is the way it connects new content to what children already know, think, and feel. The fictional context offers a bridge between curriculum demands and personal experience. When a child becomes a museum curator or an Arctic explorer, they bring their existing understandings with them. Teachers draw on this prior learning explicitly and implicitly, offering new perspectives that challenge or extend what students are already interested in. Learning becomes layered, with past knowledge recontextualised and reframed through shared inquiry.

5 Scaffolding Learning
In MoE, scaffolding happens through the shared fiction, through role, and through well-sequenced dramatic conventions. The teacher uses voice, position, language, and narrative developments to offer support, pose challenge, and adjust difficulty. Students are invited to operate at the edge of their understanding, within the safe boundaries of the imagined world. This support is dynamic, fading as children become more confident and stepping in when the demands increase. Dramatic tension in particular is used to scaffold emotional investment and empathy, motivating students to grapple with complex problems and perspectives.

6 A Range of Techniques
MoE is deliberately multi modal. It includes whole class dramatic scenes, teacher in role moments, small group discussion, investigations, writing in role, designing artefacts, and reflective inquiry. These varied approaches engage learners with different interests and serve different purposes. Some advance the narrative, others consolidate learning, and others open space for reflection. This variety supports inclusion and maintains energy across extended contexts. Teachers become adept at choosing the right convention at the right time, with intention and flexibility.

7 Higher Order Thinking and Dialogue
Dialogue is central to MoE. The approach relies on sustained, purposeful conversation, both within the fiction and about it. Students are asked to weigh possibilities, consider alternatives, justify actions, and negotiate meaning. The fictional frame allows for rich ethical dilemmas and layered interpretation, all of which support critical and creative thinking. Teachers use open ended questioning and reflective pauses, encouraging metacognition and a deep engagement with content. Through role, learners sometimes articulate views that are not their own, developing empathy, multiple perspectives, and appreciative understanding.

8 Assessment for Learning
Assessment in MoE is continuous, formative, and embedded. Teachers notice what students say, do, and suggest within the drama. These insights help to shape the next episode, the next layer of challenge, or the next moment of action. Students also assess themselves and each other, sometimes in role and sometimes outside it, reflecting on how well the team is working, what needs to be improved, and what new questions have emerged. The work is focused on the commission: urgent and important, it gives the students’ efforts meaning and purpose. While working in this way, there is always another to bear in mind – it might be an audience, a client, or someone in need. In these circumstances, reflective assessment and development are not just classroom activities but essential elements in the work of the fictional team.

9 Inclusion and Equity
MoE is designed to be inclusive. Every student is part of the team and everyone has a role. The work is inherently collaborative, with an ethic of shared responsibility and trust. There are no low status tasks and no fixed hierarchies. Because MoE builds on imagination and dialogue rather than prior attainment, it opens space for learners who might struggle in traditional settings to find voice and value. It challenges deficit views of ability and draws on the resources, successes, and hopes of all learners. In doing so, it creates a classroom culture rooted in participation, dignity, and respect.

Newsletter

Keep up-to-date with the latest news and projects.

Mailing List