Hallmark 1: Giving Serious Attention to Student Voice

12th July 2025

Tim Taylor

This post, focusing on Hallmark 1: Giving Serious Attention to Student Voice, is the second in a series about the ‘Nine Hallmarks of Great Pedagogy’, identified by Chris Husbands and Jo Pearce in their 2012 paper What Makes Great Pedagogy? Nine Claims from Research.

We won’t be looking at student voice across the whole school – things like school councils, surveys, focus groups or strategic planning. Instead, this post is about the everyday work of involving children in shaping what happens in their classrooms and giving them a say in how they learn. This is not to suggest that opportunities for students to contribute at a whole-school level aren’t important, only that those practices are well established and widely documented. What is less discussed, and less well researched, is the quieter, everyday practice of listening to students as part of the teaching and learning process, and taking their ideas seriously as a source of insight, direction and possibility.

Being Small in a Big System

Put yourself, for a moment, on the carpet space of a five-year-old. It’s the end of the last term and the school year is coming to an end. Back when you first started school, everything was new and strange: the face of your teacher, the classroom full of things you’d never seen before, the faces of your classmates – their idiosyncrasies, their needs, their bodies – everything was coming at you all at once. And at the same time, there were routines to learn, activities to take part in, and new things to understand – often weird and incomprehensible. How did you cope? How did you make it through the year? Yet here you are, and things aren’t so strange any more. You’ve got used to how things are done, and the things that once felt weird now don’t seem so odd.

For the adults in the room, it’s easy to see you as someone without much to offer: too young to contribute anything of value, too new to have original thoughts, too small to make a difference. Yet, consider the resources you’ve demonstrated to get through the year: the resilience to overcome change and to deal with the unknown, the intelligence to make sense of weird signs and to learn unfamiliar skills, the courage to speak, to try new things, to maybe fail, but to try again. You are a resourceful person, with a successful past, and, like most humans, you have hope for the future.

Your teacher is kind, but he doesn’t really listen to you. He tells you what to do and asks questions he already knows the answers to. He looks very busy, and sometimes he gets a bit grumpy. You like it when he reads stories – he uses funny voices and smiles. You like it less when you have to do things you find hard and don’t understand, like writing. It makes your hand hurt, and you’re not sure why it matters. You know it’s something adults do, but you can’t imagine why.

You have to do it every day, but nobody has explained what all this writing is for. At the end of the lesson, the adults take your writing away and do something with it. You have no idea what. You suppose it must be important. Sometimes, if you try really hard, your teacher gives you a sticker. You like stickers, but they fall off at playtime.

How we Frame Childhood

Children aren’t just little people; they are human beings. They have the same needs that all human beings have. They want some agency over their lives, some say in how things are done, and, most importantly, they want to understand what they are doing and why they are doing it. This isn’t difficult to comprehend. So why do we, the adults, struggle so much to keep it in mind?

I suspect it has something to do with the way education has framed childhood. Children at school have become cyphers in the education system. Data points listed on spreadsheets. The people who spend the most time examining this data and poring over its meaning are the furthest from actually being with children. They might visit schools occasionally, taken round the building, spending a few minutes in a classroom or watching an assembly, but they spend very little time with children and have no interest in anything that does not push the numbers further up the graph.

The message for schools – don’t do things that slow down the learning process. Lessons are about efficiency and time management. Tell the students what they need to know, practise it, and test them to check if it’s stuck. Everything else is superfluous. What does it matter what a five year old child thinks? If it slows down this process, it’s only a drag on progress, a distraction from outcomes, something to be managed or ignored.

I’m not suggesting these are bad people. They mean well and are doing what they believe is for the best. But the unintended consequences are significant and, ironically, inefficient in the long run.

Consider, for example, whether it works better for the system if students are engaged and invested in their learning, compared to students who are bored and distracted. The answer is obvious. Yet how often does the system ask this question? And if it does, does it have any answers? I suspect, not. And worse it has given up trying to think of any.

If we are to ask the question and search for an answer, we need to return to the basic truth: children are human beings with needs, questions, and a desire to understand. Think of your own life. How much time would you spend learning something if you couldn’t see the point of it? How invested would you feel? How much would you enjoy it? Yet this is, by and large, the daily experience of many students in school. It was certainly mine after a certain age.

Yet, the truth is education really is good for children. And the better they do, the more it benefits their lives. So we should do what we can to make it something they enjoy and feel part of, because that is how they learn best.

Listening to children and what they have to say is a basic requirement. Not the facile, empty kind of listening that relies on closed questions we already know the answers to. And not the tokenistic, performative kind where we ask for their thoughts on things that don’t really matter, like too many school councils. But rather, listening that gives genuine and serious attention to their thoughts, ideas, and interests, especially on things that could actually make a difference.

The real difficulty, and the one schools often struggle to overcome, is how to do this authentically while still keeping to the curriculum and making good use of limited time.

Power, Structure, and the Limits of Student Voice

Aside from a few exceptions, schools and classrooms are not democracies and students are not stakeholders or citizens. They don’t elect the people who run the school and they don’t have a genuine say over how the school is organised or how lessons are taught. That’s the role of the adults. Schools operate within society, and there are layers of power and authority. At the most distant level are the laws and regulations set by government and enforced by the legal system. At the next level are the rules and procedures determined by the school’s leadership. Closest to the students are the routines, expectations, and routines of the classroom, established and maintained by the teacher.

At this closest level students might have the opportunity to discuss the class rules and have a say in some of the ways things are done, but on the whole, their role is not to question or reason why, but to comply and do as they are told.

The same is true of the curriculum. At the national level, the government sets the curriculum and uses Ofsted (or an equivalent organisation) to enforce it. At the school level, the leadership team interprets the national framework and establishes a school curriculum that ensures breadth and progress. At the classroom level, usually it is the teacher who decides what the students will be studying from one lesson to the next. Rarely are children consulted or given a say.

And that is probably right. Children are not experts, they are not trained educationalists, and they do not yet have a full understanding of the purpose of education to make informed decisions. Once again, that responsibility lies with the adults. However, that lack of a say has some unfortunate consequences. As discussed earlier, without opportunities to have some agency over their lives, some influence over how things are done, and some understanding of what they are doing, children (like all human beings) can become demotivated and disengaged.

So, how do we square this circle? How do we give students a voice about their learning, and some understanding of what they are doing? One answer is to create a second world in the classroom, a fiction, where the children are not people without power or authority, but characters in a story. Characters with the power to influence events, make decisions, and take on responsibilities that give their actions meaning.

Creating a Story World

Here’s an example. Let’s go back to the classroom we visited earlier. Imagine, instead of closing the book at the end of the story and setting the children an unrelated task, the teacher says, “I wonder if we could go into this story and help the bear?” He shows them the last page of the book, We’re Going on a Bear Hunt. There’s a picture of the bear walking alone along a beach. “He does look a bit lonely, don’t you think?”

“Of course,” he continues, “bears can be dangerous, so we’d have to be careful. What do you think?”

The children answer enthusiastically. There’s a discussion about what they know about bears. The teacher goes back through the book, opening the pages where there are pictures of the bear and talks with the children about what these images might tell them.

“Do you think he’s angry?” The teacher asks. Some of the children think he is, others think he might just be sad.

Hmm,” the teacher says, considering their answers. “Shall we watch him at a safe distance and see what he does?”

The children agree that would be a good idea.

“Right then, everyone, stand up. Have you got your binoculars?” He enacts using a pair of binoculars, holding them up to his eyes. The children join in. “Remember, bears can be unpredictable, so keep still and keep quiet. Have you got your camouflage clothes on?”

The children say they have.

“Good,” says the teacher, “well I’ll be the bear, and you watch what he does.”

The teacher steps away from the group and rounds his shoulders, slumping his back like the bear at the end of the story.

Some of the children laugh, surprised and a bit confused seeing their teacher do this.

The teacher straightens up and comes out of the story. “I’m not doing it to make you laugh,” he says gently, helping them understand. “I’m trying to give you an idea of how the bear is feeling. Let’s try again. Please don’t laugh, no one likes being laughed at.”

The teacher goes back into the story to represent the bear. This time, the children do not laugh. They look through their binoculars, now understanding this is something happening in a story.

The bear takes a few steps, then stops. He sniffs the air and turns, as if he has heard a sound. The children hold their breadth. Satisfied there is no one there, the bear carries on.

The teacher takes a couple more steps and then comes out of the story. He returns to the carpet and invites the children to sit down.

“What did you see,” he asks.

Excitedly, the children tell him they saw the bear, it was walking slowly with a bent back, then it stopped, turned round and sniffed.

“What did you do?” the teacher asks, smiling.

“We kept really still and quiet,” the children tell him.

“Then what happened?” he asks.

The children tell him the bear turned around again and walked away.

“Hmm,” says the teacher, thinking aloud. “Do you think he went back to his cave?”

The children think he might have.

“I’m a bit worried about this bear,” the teacher says. “I’m a bit worried he might be misunderstood. But we also don’t want people just wandering into his cave, that wouldn’t end well. Before we do anything else, I think we should put up some posters to warn people there’s a bear in the area. What do you think?”

The children agree that would be a good idea.

The teacher picks up a pen and turns to the whiteboard. “Right,” he asks, “what should we put on this poster?”

The children give him suggestions, and the teacher writes them down, asking the children to sound out the words.

Soon, they have a model poster on the board:
“Warning! Bear in the area. Stay away from the cave. Very Dangerous! If you see the bear, call this number: 01545 5588.”

“That should do it,” the teacher says, putting down his pen. “Now, we’re going to need posters up all around this area. There’s some paper on the tables and some pens. Let’s get to work. You might want to draw a picture of the bear on your poster so people know what it looks like.”

The children get to work and soon there are posters up all around the classroom.

Using Story to Give Students a Say

Let’s stop here and consider how the teacher has built the fictional context and used it to give serious attention to the students’ thoughts and ideas.

Rather than closing the book and moving on to the next activity, the teacher uses the story – something he knows the children are enjoying – as the context for the next session. He wants the children to write and to apply the phonics skills they’ve been developing, so he draws on the events of the story to give their writing a clear purpose and audience. When the children help him write the poster, they understand the urgency of its message and why it matters. Their writing has meaning and value.

Further, at every step the teacher asks genuine questions and listens carefully to the children’s responses. This doesn’t mean the session loses its direction – the teacher still knows the outcome he’s working towards – but it does mean the children help shape the fictional context. They contribute details, make suggestions, and co-create the unfolding story. In doing so, they feel part of something purposeful, something with urgency and consequence.

Most importantly, they understand why they are doing what they are doing, and how it might make a difference. This isn’t just practice for something that might matter in the distant future – it has value and purpose now in the fictional world they are enjoying and invested in.

This last point is crucial. For the reasons we discussed above, it is not really practical or realistic to give children a say in how their school or classroom is run. There may be small opportunities for input, perhaps in classroom rules, or playground activities, but realistically, these choices are minor at best, and tokenistic at worst.

Where we can give students a genuine and meaningful voice is in the story worlds we create as fictional contexts for curriculum study. Within these contexts, teachers can plan what they want students to learn and what activities they will undertake, while also creating space for students to make valuable contributions, adding details, discussing how things are done, and helping to shape the direction of the work.

This is how we can square the circle and make learning something meaningful, purposeful, and enjoyable for children.

How to Take Student Voice Seriously

The following are some general principles, drawn from the example, that all teachers can follow when aiming to give serious attention to student voice:

  1. Invite Participation
    Frame learning as a shared endeavour. Ask questions that open possibilities rather than prescribe outcomes.
  2. Value Prior Knowledge
    Treat students’ existing ideas and experiences as legitimate starting points for exploration.
  3. Co-construct Meaning
    Examine materials and problems together. Use shared reference points to support discussion and interpretation.
  4. Encourage Multiple Perspectives
    Allow space for disagreement and alternative viewpoints. Resist narrowing children’s responses to a ‘right answer’.
  5. Offer Real Choices
    Build moments where students can influence decisions and help shape what happens next.
  6. Explain and Model Intentions
    When students misread a situation, take time to explain. Help them understand the purpose of the activity.
  7. Listen Closely and Follow Up
    Ask open questions and respond thoughtfully to what children say. Use their contributions to guide the direction of learning.
  8. Speculate Together
    Use wondering and ‘what if’ language to keep the learning open, imaginative, and inviting.
  9. Create Purposeful Roles and Responsibilities
    Build contexts where students’ contributions have meaning and consequence.
  10. Make Ideas Visible and Shared
    Use shared writing, drawing, or displays to record and reflect student thinking.
  11. Hand Over Control When Appropriate
    Step back and allow students to take action, showing that their thinking can shape real outcomes within the classroom context.

Newsletter

Keep up-to-date with the latest news and projects.

Mailing List